Title: Unpacking South Africa's Agricultural Landscape: A Necessary Dialogue
In a recent meeting at the White House on May 21, 2025, between South African President Cyril Ramaphosa and former US President Donald Trump, discussions on agriculture and land reform in South Africa took a concerning turn. Instead of addressing the complexities of South Africa’s agricultural landscape based on factual data, Trump’s comments erroneously suggested that “Blacks are not farmers,” perpetuating misleading narratives about the country’s farming demographics.
Agricultural economists have long emphasized the importance of an accurate portrayal of South Africa’s agriculture. Our research, notably reflected in publications such as “The Uncomfortable Truth about South Africa’s Agriculture,” illustrates that the reality is much more nuanced. Contrary to Trump’s assertions, there are significantly more Black farmers than White farmers in South Africa’s agricultural sector. However, the official data, stemming from sources like the 2017 Agricultural Census and Land Audit, are often incomplete, leading to skewed perceptions both locally and internationally.
Statistics reveal that a large proportion of farm operations in South Africa, often classified as micro or small-scale enterprises, do not fit the traditional narrative suggesting predominance of large-scale White farmers. In fact, many Black farmers are actively engaged in agriculture, contributing to the nation’s food supply despite facing challenges related to support and resources.
It is crucial to clarify that while Black farmers may comprise about 10% of South Africa’s commercial agricultural output, this statistic does not capture the entire picture. The hard work and contributions of Black South Africans are integral to the agricultural supply chain, from farming to distribution and retail. This reality, often overlooked, illustrates the rich diversity and crucial presence of Black farmers in South Africa.
After Trump’s comments, the muted response from local farmers’ organizations raises questions about their collective stance on these misrepresentations. The US remains a major export market for South Africa’s agricultural products, accounting for around 4% of the country’s total agricultural exports valued at approximately .7 billion in 2024. Therefore, it is paramount for South Africa to present a united front that accurately reflects the realities of its agricultural landscape and counters any false narratives that could harm its global economic relationships.
As agricultural economists, we call for more inclusive and representative data that can effectively advocate for the rights and identities of South African farmers, especially those from historically marginalized communities. Promoting a truthful account of agriculture in South Africa not only enriches the conversation but also ensures that all voices are heard in shaping policies that impact the future of the farming community.
Let us champion the facts and celebrate the contributions of all farmers, honoring their roles in enhancing the agricultural tapestry of South Africa.
#Politics #BusinessNews
